GRAVITATION. - I. GENERALITIES. - In the study of natural phenomena, over the course of the centuries, the opportunity has repeatedly arisen to admit the hypothesis that material bodies can, or indeed must, mutually attract one another (and sometimes possibly even repel one another) despite not being in contact or even being perceptibly distant. Clear assertions to this effect, which Empedocles, Anaxagoras and then Leucippus and Democritus placed at the foundation of their cosmogonies, are recorded in works of Plato and Aristotle, and in these are also interestingly brought close to the phenomena of the fall of heavy bodies near the earth's surface. In this field there is still found, at least latently, the admission of one of these mysterious attractions down to the time of Galileo, who, with his simultaneous discoveries of the fundamental law of dynamics and of the law of the fall of heavy bodies, was finally able to fix its fundamental character in a far clearer manner. It was in fact then proved that the earth, even considered globally, as a whole, near its surface attracted all material bodies with a force capable of imparting to them an equal acceleration (that is, an equal increase of their velocity, approximately equal to 980 centimetres per second, an acceleration which is now conventionally denoted by the letter g). It follows immediately from Galileo's dynamical law that the force of attraction on each body (that is, its weight) is necessarily proportional to its mass.
But despite the extraordinary importance of this Galilean result which, far more than his celebrated dialogues on the Chief World Systems, was the one that «all'Anglo che tanta alla visese - sgombrò primo le vie del firmamento», we are still not yet faced with the notion and the universal law of gravitation. The precise definition of that notion and the complete formulation of its law were predominantly the work of Newton.
II. THE NEWTONIAN DEDUCTION
In the first place, the Newtonian third principle of dynamics, by affirming the existence, through reaction, of an equal attraction of the body considered upon the earth, established a complete reciprocity between them. One could therefore directly extend Galileo's result by affirming that "between any two bodies of mass m and m' there always occurs an attraction proportional to the product m m' of those masses." However, the decisive step toward the conception of the universality of the phenomenon of gravitation was taken by Newton only when, to his mind occupied with the search for the cause by which the moon accompanies the earth in its motion through space (in 1666), there flashed the idea that it must consist in an attractive force mutually binding earth and moon, of the same origin and the same nature as that which, near the earth's surface, binds the earth and any material body, determining its weight and, if free, its fall with acceleration g.
On the basis of the Galilean experimental criterion, the credibility of these hypotheses could be demonstrated only by the full agreement of all their consequences with reality. The moon, by the mere fact of moving around the earth in an approximately circular orbit, is necessarily subject to a centripetal acceleration, which kinematics, already sufficiently established at that time, permits without difficulty to calculate on the basis of its distance D from the center of the earth and its period of revolution T; two quantities already then known with sufficient exactness. This centripetal acceleration turned out to be equal to 0.272 centimeters per second, that is, 3600 times weaker than that on material bodies at the earth's surface. For the credibility of the Newtonian hypothesis, the attractive force of the earth on any body situated at distance D from its center would have had to have that same value.
At this point a notable difficulty arose: the fundamental principles of Galileo-Newton had permitted, given the existence of an attractive force between two masses, to affirm that it must be proportional to their product; however, they said nothing about the dependence of such a force on their distance. But here too Newton ingeniously supplied with two other hypotheses, which then would have had to turn out a posteriori to be in full agreement with the original hypothesis. At that time it was a rather widespread opinion that the intensity of phenomena that could be considered as emanating symmetrically from a center (as, for example, light from a point source) must attenuate proportionally to the spherical surface it reached, and therefore proportionally to the square of the distance from that center. In that case, even if the emanation did not occur from the center alone, but from spherical layers symmetric about it, the effect at an external point would have to be equal to what it would have been if the entire emanation came from that center. Thus, supposing the masses of the earth distributed symmetrically about the center, Newton was able to set up his calculations as if the entire terrestrial mass were condensed at its central point. Then, indicating by R the earth's radius, and given the law admitted regarding the effect of distance, the forces and therefore the accelerations at distances R and D would have to satisfy the condition F at R: F at D = D²: R². But since the acceleration at the earth's surface a at R = 980 and that at the moon's distance a at D = 0.272 centimeters per second and therefore a at R : a at D = 3600, it follows that the ratio D/R should be equal to 60, that is, that the moon's distance should be equal to 60 R. But then, because of the inexact knowledge of R, it was believed to be only 56 R. Newton's hypothesis therefore did not turn out to be in sufficient agreement with apparent reality.
But in 1683 the new and more rigorous measurement of the meridian arc carried out by Picard became known. On the basis of it, the earth's radius turned out to be appreciably smaller than had been believed until then, and precisely about 1/60 of the moon's distance. Naturally Newton was happy to be able to reconsider his hypothesis of 1666 and in 1687, after four years of meditation and work, he published his immortal work, in which, having systematized the principles of Galileo's dynamics and his own, he gave and widely applied the classic formula of gravitational forces F
F = G · frac{M₁ M₂}{D²}
now valid for any mass in the universe, at any distance. The universal constant G was determined through successive delicate experiments, ever more exact, as G = 6.66 · 10^{-8} cm³/sec² · gr^{-1}.
But of the unlimited universality of the notion of gravitation and of its law one gains an adequate idea only when one considers it elementarily, that is, referring it to every particle of matter in the universe conceived as attracting and as attracted. The phenomena that manifest themselves are nothing but the resultants of these innumerable elementary phenomena.
III. MERITS AND DEFECTS OF THE NEWTONIAN THEORY
As regards the merits of the Newtonian conception, there is certainly no need to insist. Everyone knows that the Principia already contained, far more than in germ, the celestial mechanics that for centuries has gone from triumph to triumph by applying Newton's conception and law, valid up to inconceivable distances. And not only valid with mediocre approximations, but with approximations almost equally inconceivable. It suffices to recall that two minimal divergences, which in other natural sciences would have been considered negligible, led to the discovery of the two most distant planets of our solar system and of the strange companions of certain double stars.
But there is also no lack of some difficulty. The admission of actions between distant bodies without the intervention of a transmitting medium or, as it was immediately called, of actions at a distance, was repugnant to its very author, who insisted on declaring that he did not at all affirm that those actions were really at a distance, but only that the further phenomena unfolded as if they were effectively so. And it is worthy of note that, while contemporaries and, for two centuries, successors sought to develop numerous interpretations and theories of the phenomenon of gravitation, Newton rigorously abstained from doing so, as if he had ingeniously intuited what became evident only beyond the middle of the 19th century: "that the deepest foundations of the knowledge of nature cannot be reached with interpretations of a mechanistic type."
Another significant difficulty comes from the fact that, if one considers the universe as infinitely extended, as was practically customary in the preceding centuries, and with an average distribution of matter analogous to that of the part of it accessible to observation, the Newtonian theory could no longer be valid. For this and other difficulties v. RELATIVITY.
Bibliography2 works
P. Paolo Straneo