Lectures or Tractates on the Gospel According to St. John 72
72.1 On the Same Passage PL 35, 1822
1. It is no easy matter to comprehend what is meant by, or in what sense we are to receive, these words of the Lord, “He that believeth on me, the works that I do shall he do also:” and then, to this great difficulty in the way of our understanding, He has added another still more difficult, “And greater things than these shall he do.” What are we to make of it? We have not found one who did such works as Christ did; and are we likely to find one who will do even greater? But we remarked in our last discourse, that it was a greater deed to heal the sick by the passing of their shadow, as was done by the disciples, than as the Lord Himself did by the touch of the hem of His garment; and that more believed on the apostles than on the Lord Himself, when preaching with His own lips; so that we might suppose works like these to be understood as greater: not that the disciple was to be greater than his Master, or the servant than his Lord, or the adopted son than the Only-begotten, or man than God, but that by them He Himself would condescend to do these greater works, while telling them in another passage, “Without me ye can do nothing.” While He Himself, on the other hand, to say nothing of His other works, which are numberless, made them without any aid from themselves, and without them made this world; and because He Himself thought meet to become man, without them He made also Himself. But what have they [made or done] without Him, save sin? And last of all, He straightway also withdrew from the subject all that could cause us agitation; for after saying, “He that believeth on me, the works that I do shall he do also; and greater works than these shall he do;” He immediately went on to add, “Because I go unto the Father; and whatsoever ye shall ask in my name, that will I do.” He who had said, “He will do,” afterwards said, “I will do;” as if He had said, Let not this appear to you impossible; for he that believeth on me can never become greater than I am, but it is I who shall then be doing greater things than now; greater things by him that believeth on me, than by myself apart from him; yet it is I myself apart from him, and I myself by him [that will do the works]: and as it is apart from him, it is not he that will do them; and as, on the other hand, it is by him, although not by his own self, it is he also that will do them. And besides, to do greater things by one than apart from one, is not a sign of deficiency, but of condescension. For what can servants render unto the Lord for all His benefits towards them? And sometimes He hath condescended to number this also amongst His other benefits towards them, namely, to do greater works by them than apart from them. Did not that rich man go away sad from His presence, when seeking counsel about eternal life? He heard, and cast it away: and yet in after days the counsel that fell on his ears was followed, not by one, but by many, when the good Master was speaking by the disciples; He was an object of contempt to the rich man, when warned by Himself directly, and of love to those whom by means of poor men He transformed from rich into poor. Here, then, you see, He did greater works when preached by believers, than when speaking Himself to hearers.
Quid sibi velit, et quomodo accipiendum sit quod Dominus ait, Qui credit in me, opera quae ego facio, et ipse faciet, non est facile comprehendere: et cum hoc ad intelligendum difficillimum sit, adjecit aliud difficilius, Et majora horum faciet. Quid est hoc? Qui faceret opera quae Christus fecit, non inveniebamus; qui etiam majora faciet, inventuri sumus? Sed dixeramus sermone pristino quia majus fuit umbrae suae transitu, quod discipuli fecerunt , quam fimbriae suae tactu, quod ipse Dominus fecit , sanare languentes; et quia plures Apostolis, quam ipso per os proprium praedicante Domino crediderunt: ut haec viderentur opera intelligenda esse majora: non quo major esset Magistro discipulus, vel Domino servus, vel adoptatus Unigenito, vel homo Deo; sed quod per illos ipse dignaretur eadem majora facere, qui dicit illis alio loco, Sine me nihil potestis facere . Ipse quippe, ut alia emittam, quae sunt innumerabilia, sine ipsis fecit eos, sine ipsis fecit hunc mundum; et quia homo etiam ipse fieri dignatus est, sine ipsis fecit et seipsum. Quid autem illi sine ipso, nisi peccatum? Denique et hic id quod de hac re poterat nos movere, mox abstulit: cum enim dixisset, Qui credit in me, opera quae ego facio, et ipse faciet, et majora horum faciet; continuo secutus adjunxit, Quia ego ad Patrem vado, et quaecumque petieritis, in nomine meo, haec faciam. Qui dixerat faciet, post ait faciam; tanquam diceret, Non vobis impossibile hoc videatur: non enim poterit esse major me qui credit in me, sed ego facturus sum et tunc majora quam nunc; majora per eum qui credit in me, quam praeter eum per me: ego tamen ipse praeter eum, ego ipse per eum: sed quando praeter eum, non faciet ipse; quando autem per eum, quamvis non per semetipsum, faciet et ipse. Porro autem majora facere per eum quam praeter eum, non est defectio, sed dignatio. Quid enim retribuant servi Domino, pro omnibus quae retribuit eis ? Quandoquidem inter caetera bona etiam hoc eis donare dignatus est, ut majora faceret per illos quam praeter illos. Nonne ab ore illius dives ille tristis abscessit, quando vitae aeternae consilium quaesivit ? Audivit, abjecit: et tamen postea quod ab illo auditum non fecit unus, fecerunt multi, cum loqueretur per discipulos magister bonus; contemptibilis ei quem divitem per seipsum monuit, amabilis eis quos ex divitibus pauperes per pauperes fecit. Ecce majora fecit praedicatus a credentibus, quam locutus audientibus.
72.2 PL 35, 1823
2. But there is still something to excite thought in His doing such greater works by the apostles; for He said not, as if merely with reference to them, The works that I do shall ye do also; and greater works than these shall ye do: but wishing to be understood as speaking of all that belonged to His family, said, “He that believeth on me, the works that I do shall he do also; and greater works than these shall he do.” If, then, he that believeth shall do such works, he that shall do them not is certainly no believer: just as “He that loveth me, keepeth my commandments,” implies, of course, that he who keepeth them not, loveth not. In another place, also, He says, “He that heareth these sayings of mine and doeth them, I will liken him unto a wise man, who buildeth his house upon a rock;” and he, therefore, who is unlike this wise man, without doubt either heareth these sayings and doeth them not, or faileth even to hear them. “He that believeth in me,” He says, “though he die, yet shall he live;” and he, therefore, that shall not live, is certainly no believer now. In a similar way, also, it is said here, “He that believeth in me shall do [such works]:” he is, therefore, no believer who shall not do so. What have we here, then, brethren? Is it that one is not to be reckoned among believers in Christ, who shall not do greater works than Christ? It were hard, unreasonable, intolerable, to suppose so; that is, unless it be rightly understood. Let us listen, then, to the apostle, when he says, “To him that believeth on Him that justifieth the ungodly, his faith is counted for righteousness.” This is the work in which we may be doing the works of Christ, for even our very believing in Christ is the work of Christ. It is this He worketh in us, not certainly without us. Hear now, then, and understand, “He that believeth on me, the works that I do shall he do also:” I do them first, and he shall do them afterwards; for I do such works that he may do them also. And what are the works, but the making of a righteous man out of an ungodly one?
Verum hoc adhuc movet, quod haec majora per Apostolos fecit: non autem ipsos tantum significans ait, Opera quae ego facio et vos facietis, et majora horum facietis: sed omnes ad suam familiam pertinentes intelligi volens, Qui credit in me, inquit, opera quae ego facio, et ipse faciet, et majora horum faciet. Si ergo qui credit faciet, non credit utique qui non faciet: sicuti est, Qui diligit me, mandata mea custodit ; unde profecto qui non custodit, non diligit. Item alio loco, Qui audit, inquit, verba mea haec et facit ea, similabo eum viro prudenti qui aedificat domum suam supra petram : qui ergo non est similis huic viro prudenti, procul dubio aut verba haec audit et non facit, aut omnino nec audit. Qui credit, inquit, in me, licet moriatur, vivet : qui ergo non vivet, non utique credit. Tale etiam hoc est, Qui credit in me, faciet: non utique credit qui non faciet. Quid est hoc, fratres? Numquid inter credentes in Christum non est computandus, qui non fecerit opera majora quam Christus? Durum est, absurdum est, ferri non potest: non toleratur nisi intelligatur. Apostolum igitur audiamus: Credenti, inquit, in eum qui justificat impium, deputatur fides ejus ad justitiam . In hoc opere faciamus opera Christi, quia et ipsum credere in Christum, opus est Christi. Hoc operatur in nobis, non utique sine nobis. Audi ergo jam, et intellige, Qui credit in me, opera quae ego facio, et ipse faciet: prius ego facio, deinde et ipse faciet; quia facio ut faciat. Quae opera, nisi ut ex impio justus fiat?
72.3 PL 35, 1823
3. “And greater works than these shall he do.” Than what, pray? Shall we say that one is doing greater works than all that Christ did who is working out his own salvation with fear and trembling? A work which Christ is certainly working in him, but not without him; and one which I might, without hesitation, call greater than the heavens and the earth, and all in both within the compass of our vision. For both heaven and earth shall pass away, but the salvation and justi fication of those predestinated thereto, that is, of those whom He foreknoweth, shall continue forever. In the former there is only the working of God, but in the latter there is also His image. But there are also in the heavens, thrones, governments, principalities, powers, archangels, and angels, which are all of them the work of Christ; and is it, then, greater works also than these that he doeth, who, with Christ working in him, is a co-worker in his own eternal salvation and justification? I dare not call for any hurried decision on such a point: let him who can, understand, and let him who can, judge whether it is a greater work to create righteous beings than to make righteous the ungodly. For at least, if there is equal power employed in both, there is greater mercy in the latter. For “this is the great mystery of godliness which was manifested in the flesh, justified in the Spirit, seen of angels, preached unto the Gentiles, believed on in the world, received up into glory.” But when He said, “Greater works than these shall he do,” there is no necessity requiring us to suppose that all of Christ’s works are to be understood. For He spake, perhaps, only of these He was now doing; and the work He was doing at that time was uttering the words of faith, and of such works specially had He spoken just before when He said, “The words that I speak unto you, I speak not of myself: but the Father, that dwelleth in me, He doeth the works.” His words, accordingly, were His works. And it is assuredly something less to preach the words of righteousness, which He did apart from us, than to justify the ungodly, which He does in such a way in us that we also are doing it ourselves. It remains for us to inquire how the words are to be understood, “Whatsoever ye shall ask in my name, I will do it.” Because of the many things His believing ones ask, and receive not, there is no small question claiming our attention; but as this discourse must now be concluded, we must allow at least a little delay for its consideration and discussion.
Et majora horum faciet. Quorum, obsecro? Numquidnam omnium operum Christi majora facit, qui cum timore et tremore suam ipsius salutem operatur ? Quod utique in illo, sed non sine illo Christus operatur. Prorsus majus hoc esse dixerim, quam est coelum et terra, et quaecumque cernuntur in coelo et in terra. Et coelum enim et terra transibit ; praedestinatorum autem, id est eorum quos praescit, salus et justificatio permanebit. In illis tantum opera Dei, in his autem etiam est imago Dei. Sed et in coelis, Sedes, Dominationes, Principatus, Potestates, Archangeli, Angeli opera sunt Christi; numquid etiam his operibus majora facit, qui operante in se Christo, cooperatur aeternam salutem ac justificationem suam? Non hic audeo praecipitare sententiam: intelligat qui potest, judicet qui potest, utrum majus sit justos creare quam impios justificare. Certe enim si aequalis est utrumque potentiae, hoc majoris est misericordiae. Hoc est enim magnum pietatis sacramentum, quod manifestatum est in carne, justificatum est in Spiritu, apparuit Angelis, praedicatum est in gentibus, creditum est in mundo, assumptum est in gloria . Sed omnia opera Christi intelligere ubi ait, Majora horum faciet, nulla nos necessitas cogit. Horum enim forsitan dixit, quae in illa hora faciebat: tunc autem verba fidei faciebat, et de his operibus fuerat praelocutus dicens, Verba quae ego loquor vobis, a meipso non loquor: Pater autem in me manens, ipse facit opera. Tunc igitur verba ejus erant opera ejus. Et utique minus est verba justitiae praedicare, quod fecit praeter nos, quam impios justificare, quod ita facit in nobis, ut faciamus et nos. Restat inquirere quomodo accipiendum sit, Quodcumque petieritis in nomine meo, hoc faciam. Propter multa enim quae petunt fideles ejus, nec accipiunt, non parva hinc exoritur quaestio: sed quoniam sermo iste jam claudendus est, ei considerandae atque tractandae tribuatur saltem parva dilatio.