Enciclopedia Cattolica Vol. XI, 1953 Moral theology Commandments and precepts

Scandal

SCANDALO

Italian original Cite

SCANDAL. - Here it means everything that can constitute a difficulty in the exercise of good or be a direct incentive to sin, that is, to moral evil.

In this sense, already in the Old Testament it is said, for example, that God, to test the virtue of the righteous man, will place "offendiculum coram eo" (Ezek. 3:20); and, in the New, Jesus says that the world is full of scandal and that, indeed, in the present order of things, it cannot be otherwise. It can have its origin in the wickedness of men. The Savior sternly warns those especially who offend the little ones, saying that it would be better for a millstone to be hung around their neck and for them to end up at the bottom of the sea (Matt. 18:6; Mark 9:41; Luke 17:2). At other times the blame lies with the nature of things - our own nature, our faculties - etc. And it is in relation to this kind of scandal that Jesus says that if the foot or the hand scandalize us, it is better to cut them off without pity. At still other times scandal comes about through the very loving action of God in the world; as when it is said that the Savior has come for the fall and the resurrection of many, thus made a sign of contradiction (Luke 2:34). And blessed are those who will find in the humiliations of the Savior no cause of scandal (Matt. 11:6; Luke 7:23).

With particular insistence the New Testament returns to the duty of not giving scandal. To avoid it, Jesus miraculously causes Peter to find the coin with which to pay the tribute (Matt. 17:26) and St. Paul, although he has demonstrated that there is nothing evil in itself in the use of foods impure according to the Mosaic law, forbids it to the Christian whenever this can create some difficulty for the brethren (1 Cor. 8-10; Rom. 10).

I. SIN OF SCANDAL

In this case, scandal consists in that which impels to sin, not in the sin to which one is impelled; for scandal there is required, and it suffices, an external act or fact, bad in effect or in appearance, capable, in the concrete, of exercising a morally deleterious influence on others. Only under such conditions can there be scandal, just as, on the other hand, one can sin without there having been that particular stimulus to which the name of scandal is given.

The impulse to evil, included in the concept of scandal, can derive from the very nature of the act and of the external scandalous phenomenon, or else from the condition of the subject upon whom that act exercises its influence. In the first case the scandal will have universal value; in the second case, however, it will be such only for certain persons. There can be, in any event, a very great variety in scandals, ranging from the extreme of facts objectively very dangerous, but not dangerous in fact because of the particular conditions of the persons, to the extreme of facts objectively scarcely dangerous, but in fact most dangerous for the same reason; therefore facts and persons, conditions of time and place must be kept in mind: what could be a motive of scandal in the past is no longer so today, and vice versa; thus in other cases persons physically and spiritually immature can receive scandal, and not persons who are mature.

The evil that gives occasion to scandal can be neither foreseen nor willed by the author of the scandal, or foreseen and willed; or foreseen and not willed; moreover it can be willed solely for an advantage that one hopes to derive from it, or else out of delight in the spiritual harm of the one scandalized or in the offense to God. When the fault consequent upon the scandal is foreseen and not willed, moralists speak of indirect scandal; when, however, it is foreseen and willed, they speak of direct scandal. Scandal is called diabolical when the fault is willed for the spiritual harm of the one scandalized and for the offense that will come to God from it; it is called pharisaic when the evil derives solely from the malice of the one who commits it, without there having been an incentive or true and proper scandal, but only a pretext. Moralists then proceed to examine in depth the motives for avoiding scandal. The first and fundamental one is the obligation one has to love one's neighbor as oneself, thereby avoiding what can harm him, and to procure his good.

Its gravity will vary according to the nature of the stimulus included in the scandal and according to the person who exercises it and the person upon whom it falls; that is, it will be all the more grave the greater the impulse to sin is by the very nature of the act performed, or by the quality of the person who performs it, or by the person who is scandalized. In direct scandal there is added, to the fault against charity, a fault with respect to the virtue against which, by means of the scandal, one is impelled to sin.

The principal difficulty in this matter concerns the possibility of avoiding all scandals and the obligation that follows from it. The difficulty has been resolved by means of the well-known principle of the double effect, or, in other words, by means of the principle of the greater good or the lesser evil. The whole difficulty lies in seeing in the concrete where the greater good or the lesser evil lies; which evidently can have, in different cases, the most diverse solutions.

II. THE CRIME OF SCANDAL

The exterior aspect of scandal, involving harm to one's neighbor, has drawn the attention of the ecclesiastical legislator, who in more than one case has established penalties against the authors of scandal. Can. 2218 § 1 of the CIC states that "in poenis decernendis servetur aequa proportio cum delicto, habita ratione imputabilitatis, scandali et damni...". And can. 2222 § 1 states that "Licet lex nullam sanctionem appositam habeat, legitimus tamen Superior potest illius transgressionem, etiam sine praevia poenae comminatione, aliqua iusta poena punire, si scandalum forte datum aut specialis transgressionis gravitas id ferat". In particular, special measures are provided for religious (cann. 653, 668), for parish priests (can. 2147 §2), for non-resident clerics (cann. 2168-75), for concubinarian clerics (cann. 2176-81), for negligent parish priests (cann. 2182-85). The reparation of the scandal or a serious promise to do so is a condition for assessing the cessation of contumacy in the case of a censure (can. 2242 § 3). Absolution from every censure in the internal forum, once the scandal has been removed, may be made valid in the external forum (can. 2251).

The civil legislator has also dealt repeatedly with scandal, for example, in art. 527 of the Italian Penal Code, where penalties are imposed against "whoever, in a public place or a place open to the public or exposed to the public, commits obscene acts"; in art. 726, where other penalties are imposed for "acts contrary to public decency". More detailed ministerial provisions on the matter have recently been issued; specifically, through the provisions of the Ministry of the Interior for morality on beaches.

For spectacles and treatments contrary to morality and good morals, measures are taken by art. 70 of the Public Security law and art. 126 of the Public Security regulations, by the law of 26 April 1934, no. 653, and art. 138 of the Public Security regulations. For the public display of printed matter and, in general, of objects that offend the moral sense of modesty and good morals, provisions are taken in arts. 528, 529 and 725 of the Penal Code, in arts. 112 and 69 of the Public Security law, and in art. 125 of the Public Security regulations. From the standpoint of scandal, incest is dealt with in art. 564 of the Penal Code. A specific offense, provided for by art. 530 of the Penal Code, is the corruption of minors (cf. arts. 519-21 and the entry MINORENNI). Art. 553 of the Penal Code punishes "whoever publicly incites practices against procreation or propagandizes in their favor". For prostitution see art. 192 of the Public Security law, which authorizes the local public security authority to prevent a premises from being used for purposes of prostitution, whenever it deems it opportune in the interest of public morality, good morals or public order.

As can be seen, civil legislation on the matter of scandal is neither scanty nor unsuitable; provided that there is no lack of constant and vigorous determination on the part of those who ought to see to its enforcement.

Bibliography7 works
BIBL.: cf. the various treatises on morals in the de charitate; on canon law in the de delictis; and furthermore G. J. Waffleart, L'espèce du scandale, Bruges 1894; B. Valay, Fraternal charity, New York 1908; F. Ter Haar, Casus conscientiae, I, De praecipuis huius aetatis peccandi occasionibus, Turin-Rome 1939; J. A. Costello, Moral obligation of fraternal correction, Washington 1940, passim; N. Jung, Scandale, in DThC, XIV, coll. 1246-54.

Giovanni B. Guzzetti

About this entry

By Giovanni Battista Guzzetti

How we know signed in print

Translated from the Enciclopedia Cattolica, vol. XI (1953), coll. 11–13.

Printed pages Open in the page viewer
Page 32
vol. 11, coll. 11–12
Page 33
vol. 11, coll. 13–14

More by Giovanni Battista Guzzetti: Strike · Seduction · Secret · Lockout · Rotary Club

Cite this article

Chicago

Guzzetti, Giovanni Battista. “Scandalo.” In Enciclopedia Cattolica, vol. XI, coll. 11–13. Città del Vaticano: Ente per l’Enciclopedia Cattolica e per il Libro Cattolico, 1953. https://azioneromana.com/article/scandalo.

MLA

Guzzetti, Giovanni Battista. “Scandalo.” Enciclopedia Cattolica, vol. XI, Ente per l’Enciclopedia Cattolica e per il Libro Cattolico, 1953, coll. 11–13. Azione Romana, https://azioneromana.com/article/scandalo.

BibTeX

@incollection{ec11_scandalo,
  author    = {Guzzetti, Giovanni Battista},
  title     = {Scandalo},
  booktitle = {Enciclopedia Cattolica},
  volume    = {XI},
  pages     = {11--13},
  note      = {Cited by column},
  publisher = {Ente per l’Enciclopedia Cattolica e per il Libro Cattolico},
  address   = {Città del Vaticano},
  year      = {1953},
  url       = {https://azioneromana.com/article/scandalo}
}

One of some 20,000 entries brought back from the twelve printed volumes (1948–54). Spotted something? Help us improve it.

Save for later

Enter your email and we will send you a sign-in link. No password. What you save (articles, verses, chapters, documents) follows you to any device.