Sermons on Selected Lessons of the New Testament 12

St Augustine of Hippo (AD 354–430) · Sermones de Scripturis · PL 38, 332–799

12.0 On the words of the Gospel, Matt. viii. 8, ‘I am not worthy that thou shouldest come under my roof,’ etc., and of the words of the apostle, 1 Cor. viii. 10, ‘For if a man see thee who hast knowledge sitting at meat in an idol’s temple,’ etc PL 38, 414

[LXII. Ben.]

On the words of the Gospel, Matt. viii. 8, “I am not worthy that thou shouldest come under my roof,” etc., and of the words of the apostle, 1 Cor. viii. 10, “For if a man see thee who hast knowledge sitting at meat in an idol’s temple,” etc.

12.1 On the words of the Gospel, Matt. viii. 8, ‘I am not worthy that thou shouldest come under my roof,’ etc., and of the words of the apostle, 1 Cor. viii. 10, ‘For if a man see thee who hast knowledge sitting at meat in an idol’s temple,’ etc PL 38, 414

1. We have heard, as the Gospel was being read, the praise of our faith as manifested in humility. For when the Lord Jesus promised that He would go to the Centurion’s house to heal His servant, He answered, “I am not worthy that Thou shouldest come under my roof: but speak the word only, and he shall be healed.” By calling himself unworthy, he showed himself worthy for Christ to come not into his house, but into his heart. Nor would he have said this with so great faith and humility, had he not borne Him in his heart, of whose coming into his house he was afraid. For it were no great happiness for the Lord Jesus to enter into his house, and yet not to be in his heart. For this Master of humility both by word and example, sat down even in the house of a certain proud Pharisee, by name Simon; and though He sat down in his house, there was no place in this heart, “where the Son of Man could lay His Head.”

Centurionis humilitas. Audivimus, cum Evangelium legeretur, fidem nostram in humilitate laudari. Ad domum quippe Centurionis cum se promitteret Dominus Jesus iturum, ut puerum ejus sanaret, ille respondit: Non sum dignus ut sub tectum meum intres: sed tantum dic verbum, et sanabitur. Dicendo se indignum, praestitit dignum; non in cujus parietes, sed in cujus cor Christus intraret. Neque hoc diceret cum tanta fide et humilitate, nisi illum, quem timebat intrare in domum suam, corde gestaret. Nam non erat magna felicitas, si Dominus Jesus intraret in parietes ejus, et non esset in pectore ejus. Magister quippe humilitatis et verbo et exemplo, discubuit et in domo cujusdam pharisaei superbi, nomine Simonis . Et cum in domo ejus recumberet, non erat in corde ejus ubi caput Filius hominis reclinaret.

12.2 PL 38, 415

2. For so, as we may understand from the words of the Lord Himself, did He call back from His discipleship a certain proud man, who of his own accord was desirous to go with Him. “Lord, I will follow Thee whithersoever Thou goest.” And the Lord seeing in his heart what was invisible, said, “Foxes have holes, and the birds of the air have nests, but the Son of Man hath not where to lay His Head.” That is, in thee, guile like the fox doth dwell, and pride as the birds of heaven. But the Son of Man simple as opposed to guile, lowly as opposed to pride, hath not where to lay His Head; and this very laying, not the raising up of the head, teaches humility. Therefore doth He call back this one who was desirous to go, and another who refused He draweth onward. For in the same place He saith to a certain man, “Follow Me.” And he said, “I will follow Thee, Lord, but let me first go and bury my father.” His excuse was indeed a dutiful one: and therefore was he the more worthy to have his excuse removed, and his calling confirmed. What he wished to do was an act of dutifulness; but the Master taught him what he ought to prefer. For He wished him to be a preacher of the living word, to make others live. But there were others by whom that first necessary office might be fulfilled. “Let the dead,” He saith, “bury their dead.” When unbelievers bury a dead body, the dead bury the dead. The body of the one hath lost its soul, the soul of the others hath lost God. For as the soul is the life of the body; so is God the life of the soul. As the body expires when it loses the soul, so doth the soul expire when it loses God. The loss of God is the death of the soul: the loss of the soul the death of the body. The death of the body is necessary; the death of the soul voluntary.

Superbus a discipulatu Christi repulsus. Vita animae, Deus. Ita enim quemdam superbum, quantum intelligitur ex verbis ipsius Domini, ultro secum ire cupientem, a suo discipulatu revocavit. Sequar te, Domine, ait, quocumque ieris. Et Dominus in ejus corde invisibilia videns: Vulpes, inquit, foveas habent, et volatilia coeli nidos: Filius autem hominis non habet ubi caput suum reclinet. Hoc est, Habitant in te insidiae sicut vulpes, habitat superbia sicut coeli volatilia: Filius autem hominis simplex contra insidias, humilis contra superbiam, non habet ubi caput suum reclinet. Et ipsa reclinatio capitis, non erectio, humilitatis magistra est. Revocat ergo istum ire cupientem, trahit alium recusantem. Eodem quippe loco ait cuidam: Sequere me. Et ille: Sequar te, Domine: sed sine me primo ire et sepelire patrem meum. Pie quidem excusavit: et ideo dignior cujus excusatio removeretur, vocatio firmaretur. Pium erat quod volebat facere: sed docuit magister quid deberet praeponere. Volebat enim eum esse vivi verbi praedicatorem, ad faciendos victuros. Erant autem alii, per quos illa necessitas impleretur. Sine, inquit, mortuos sepelire mortuos suos . Infideles cadaver quando sepeliunt, mortui mortuum sepeliunt. Illius corpus animam perdidit: illorum anima Deum. Sicut enim vita corporis anima est: sic vita animae Deus. Sicut exspirat corpus, cum animam emittit: ita exspirat anima, cum Deum amittit. Deus amissus, mors animae: anima emissa, mors corporis. Mors corporis necessaria: mors animae voluntaria.

12.3 PL 38, 415

3. The Lord then sat down in the house of a certain proud Pharisee. He was in his house, as I have said, and was not in his heart. But into this centurion’s house He entered not, yet He possessed his heart. Zacchæus again received the Lord both in house and heart. Yet the centurion’s faith is praised for its humility. For he said, “I am not worthy that Thou shouldest come under my roof;” and the Lord said, “Verily I say unto you, I have not found so great faith, no, not in Israel;” according to the flesh, that is. For he too was an Israelite undoubtedly according to the spirit. The Lord had come to fleshly Israel, that is, to the Jews, there to seek first for the lost sheep, among this people, and of this people also He had assumed His Body. “I have not found there so great faith,” He saith. We can but measure the faith of men, as men can judge of it; but He who saw the inward parts, He whom no man can deceive, gave His testimony to this man’s heart, hearing words of lowliness, and pronouncing a sentence of healing.

Centurionis fides in humilitate. Discumbebat ergo Dominus in domo pharisaei cujusdam superbi. In domo ejus erat, ut dixi; et in pectore ejus non erat. In hujus vero Centurionis domum non intravit, et pectus possedit. Zacchaeus vero Dominum et domo suscepit, et animo . Hujus tamen fides in humilitate laudatur. Dixit enim, Non sum dignus ut sub tectum meum intres. Et Dominus, Amen dico vobis, non inveni tantam fidem in Israel: secundum carnem. Nam et iste jam Israelites erat secundum spiritum. Venerat Dominus ad Israelem carnalem, id est, ad Judaeos, ibi primum quaerere oves perditas, in quo populo, et de quo populo etiam corpus assumpserat: Non ibi inveni tantam fidem, ipse dicit. Possumus nos metiri fidem hominum, sicut homines: ille qui interiora cernebat, ille quem nemo fallebat, perhibuit testimonium cordi hominis, audiens verba humilitatis, pronuntians sententiam sanitatis.

12.4 PL 38, 416

4. But whence did he get such confidence? “I also,” saith he, “am a man set under authority, having soldiers under me: and I say to this man, Go, and he goeth; and to another, Come, and he cometh: and to my servant, Do this, and he doeth it.” I am an authority to certain who are placed under me, being myself placed under a certain authority above me. If then I a man under authority have the power of commanding, what power must Thou have, whom all powers serve? Now this man was of the Gentiles, for he was a centurion. At that time the Jewish nation had soldiers of the Roman empire among them. There he was engaged in a military life, according to the extent of a centurion’s authority, both under authority himself, and having authority over others; as a subject obedient, ruling others who were under him. But the Lord (and mark this especially, Beloved, as need there is you should), though He was among the Jewish people only, even now announced beforehand that the Church should be in the whole world, for the establishment of which He would send Apostles; Himself not seen, yet believed on by the Gentiles: by the Jews seen, and put to death. For as the Lord did not in body enter into this man’s house, and still, though in body absent, yet present in majesty, healed his faith, and his house; so the same Lord also was in body among the Jewish people only: among the other nations He was neither born of a Virgin, nor suffered, nor walked, nor endured His human sufferings, nor wrought His divine miracles. None of all this took place in the rest of the nations, and yet was that fulfilled which was spoken of Him, “A people whom I have not known, hath served Me.” And how if it did not know Him? “Hath obeyed Me by the hearing of the ear.” The Jewish nation knew, and crucified Him; the whole world besides heard and believed.

In centurione Gentes figuratae. Unde autem hoc praesumpsit? Et ego, inquit, homo sum sub potestate constitutus, habens sub me milites; et dico huic, Vade, et vadit; et alii, Veni, et venit; et servo meo, Fac hoc, et facit. Potestas sum quibusdam sub me positis, positus sub potestate quadam super me. Si ergo ego, inquit, homo sub potestate, jubendi habeo potestatem; quid tu possis, cui omnes serviunt potestates? Erat autem iste de Gentibus: erat quippe centurio. Jam Judaea gens habebat militem Romani imperii. Ibi iste militem agebat, quantum agere centurio poterat; et sub potestate, et habens potestatem; subditus obediens, subditos regens. Dominus autem (quod intendat praecipue necessario Charitas vestra), quamvis in populo Judaico esset, jam pronuntiabat Ecclesiam toto orbe terrarum futuram, in quam erat missurus Apostolos: ipse a Gentibus non visus et creditus, a Judaeis visus et occisus. Quomodo enim domum hujus Dominus corpore non intravit, et ejus tamen fidem atque ipsam domum absens corpore, praesens majestate sanavit: sic et idem Dominus in solo Judaeo populo corpore fuit; apud alias gentes nec de virgine natus est, nec passus est, nec pedibus ambulavit, nec humana pertulit, nec divina mirabilia fecit. Nihil horum in caeteris gentibus: et tamen de illo impletum est, quod dictum erat, Populus quem non cognovi, servivit mihi. Quomodo, si non cognovit? In auditu auris obedivit mihi . Judaea gens cognovit, et crucifixit: orbis terrarum audivit, et credidit.

12.5 PL 38, 416

5. This absence, so to say, of His body, and presence of His power among all nations, He signified also in the instance of that woman who had touched the edge of His garment, when He asketh, saying, “Who touched Me?” He asketh, as though He were absent; as though present, He healeth. “The multitude,” say the disciples, “press Thee, and sayest Thou, Who touched Me?” For as if He were so walking as not to be touched by anybody at all, He said, “Who touched Me?” And they answer, “The multitude press Thee.” And the Lord would seem to say, I am asking for one who touched, not for one who pressed Me. In this case also is His Body now, that is, His Church. The faith of the few “touches” it, the throng of the many “press” it. For ye have heard, as being her children, that Christ’s Body is the Church, and if ye will, ye yourselves are so. This the Apostle says in many places, “For His body’s sake, which is the Church;” and again, “But ye are the body of Christ, and members in particular.” If then we are His body, what His body then suffered in the crowd, that doth His Church suffer now. It is pressed by many, touched by few. The flesh presses it, faith touches it. Lift up therefore your eyes, I beseech you, ye who have wherewithal to see. For ye have before you something to see. Lift up the eyes of faith, touch but the extreme border of His garment, it will be sufficient for saving health.

Mulier tangens fimbriam Christi, cum eum turba premit. Hanc quodam modo absentiam corporis sui et praesentiam virtutis suae in omnibus Gentibus, et in illa muliere significavit, quae fimbriam vestimenti ejus tetigerat, cum requirit dicens: Quis me tetigit? Tanquam absens, requirit: tanquam praesens, sanat. Turbae te, inquiunt discipuli, comprimunt, et dicis: Quis me tetigit ? Quasi enim sic ambularet, ut a nullo prorsus corpore tangeretur, ita dixit, Quis me tetigit? Et illi, Turbae te comprimunt. Et tanquam diceret Dominus, Tangentem quaero, non prementem. Sic etiam nunc est corpus ejus, id est, Ecclesia ejus. Tangit eam fides paucorum, premit turba multorum. Corpus enim Christi esse Ecclesiam, tanquam filii ejus, audistis: et si vultis, ipsi estis. Apostolus multis locis hoc dicit: Pro corpore, inquit, ejus quae est Ecclesia . Et iterum: Vos autem estis corpus Christi et membra . Si ergo corpus ejus sumus, quod tunc corpus ipsius in turba patiebatur, hoc patitur Ecclesia ipsius. A turbis premitur: a paucis tangitur. Caro eam premit, fides tangit. Erigite igitur oculos, obsecro vos, qui habetis unde videatis. Habetis enim quod videatis. Erigite oculos fidei, tangite extremam fimbriam vestimenti, sufficiet ad salutem.

12.6 PL 38, 417

6. See ye how that which ye have heard out of the Gospel was at that time to come is now present. Therefore, said He, on occasion of the commendation of the Centurion’s faith, as in the flesh an alien, but of the household in heart, “Therefore I say unto you, Many shall come from the east and west.” Not all, but “many;” yet they shall “come from the East and West;” the whole world is denoted by these two parts. “Many shall come from the east and west, and shall sit down with Abraham, and Isaac, and Jacob, in the kingdom of heaven; but the children of the kingdom shall be cast out into outer darkness.” “But the children of the kingdom,” the Jews, namely. And how “the children of the kingdom”? Because they received the Law; to them the Prophets were sent, with them was the temple and the Priesthood; they celebrated the figures of all the things to come. Yet of what things they celebrated the figures, they acknowledged not the presence. And, “Therefore the children of the kingdom,” He saith, shall go into outer darkness, there shall be wailing and gnashing of teeth.” And so we see the Jews reprobate, and Christians called from the East and West, to the heavenly banquet, to sit down with Abraham, and Isaac, and Jacob, where the bread is righteousness, and the cup wisdom.

Impletum nunc quod in Evangelio praedicebatur. Judaei quare filii regni. Videte quod audistis ex Evangelio tunc futurum, tunc praesens est. Ideo, inquit, dico vobis: propter laudatam Centurionis fidem, tanquam alienigenae carne, domestici corde Propterea, inquit, multi ab oriente et occidente venient. Non omnes, sed multi: tamen ipsi ab oriente et occidente: istis duabus partibus totus orbis designatur. Multi ab oriente et occidente venient, et recumbent cum Abraham, et Isaac, et Jacob, in regno coelorum: filii autem regni ejicientur in tenebras exteriores. Filii autem regni, Judaei scilicet. Unde filii regni? Quia Legem acceperunt, ad quos Prophetae missi sunt, apud quos templum et sacerdotium fuit, qui celebrabant figuras omnium futurorum. Quarum enim rerum figuras celebraverunt, praesentiam non agnoverunt. Filii ergo regni ibunt, inquit, in tenebras exteriores; ibi erit ploratus et stridor dentium. Videmus Judaeos reprobatos, videmus Christianos ab oriente et occidente vocatos ad quoddam convivium coeleste, ut recumbant cum Abraham et Isaac et Jacob; ubi panis justitia, ubi potus sapientia.

12.7 PL 38, 417

7. Consider then, brethren, for of these are ye; ye are of this people, even then foretold, and now exhibited. Yes, verily, ye are of those who have been called from the East and West, to sit down in the kingdom of heaven, not in the temple of idols. Be ye then the Body of Christ, not the pressure of His Body. Ye have the border of His garment to touch, that ye may be healed of the issue of blood, that is, of carnal pleasures. Ye have, I say, the border of the garment to touch. Look upon the Apostles as the garment, by the texture of unity clinging closely to the sides of Christ. Among these Apostles was Paul, as it were the border, the least and last; as he saith himself, “I am the least of the Apostles.” In a garment the last and least thing is the border. The border is in appearance contemptible, yet is it touched with saving efficacy. “Even to this hour we both hunger and thirst, and are naked and buffeted.” What state so low, so contemptible as this! Touch then, if thou art suffering from a bloody flux. There will go power out of Him whose garment it is, and it will heal thee. The border was proposed to you just now to be touched, when out of the same Apostle there was read, “For if any one see him which hath knowledge sit at meat in an idol’s temple, shall not the conscience of him who is weak, be emboldened to eat things offered to idols? And through thy knowledge shall thy weak brother perish, for whom Christ died!” How think ye may men be deceived by idols, which they suppose are honoured by Christians? A man may say, “God knows my heart.” Yes, but thy brother did not know thy heart. If thou art weak, beware of a still greater weakness; if thou art strong, have a care of thy brother’s weakness. They who see what you do, are emboldened to do more, so as to desire not only to eat, but also to sacrifice there. And lo, “Through thy knowledge the weak brother perisheth.” Hear then, my brother; if thou didst disregard the weak, wouldest thou disregard a brother also? Awake. What if so thou sin against Christ Himself? For attend to what thou canst not by any means disregard. “But,” saith he, “when ye sin so against the brethren, and wound their weak conscience, ye sin against Christ.” Let them who disregard these words, go now, and sit at meat in the idol’s temple; will they not be of those who press, and do not touch? And when they have been at meat in the idol’s temple, let them come and fill the Church; not to receive saving health, but to make a pressure there.

Reprehenduntur in idolio convivantes cum Paganis. Attendite ergo, fratres: hoc enim estis, ex hoc populo estis, jam tunc praedicto, nunc praesentato. De his utique estis, qui vocati sunt ab oriente et occidente recumbere in regno coelorum, non in templo idolorum. Estote ergo corpus Christi, non pressura corporis Christi. Habetis vestimenti fimbriam, quam tangatis, ut a profluvio sanguinis, id est, carnalium voluptatum fluxu sanemini. Habetis, inquam, vestimenti fimbriam, quam tangatis. Vestem putate Apostolos, sub textura unitatis adhaerentes lateribus Christi. In his Apostolis erat tanquam fimbria minimus et novissimus Paulus: ipso dicente, Ego sum minimus Apostolorum . In veste novissimum et minimum, fimbria est. Fimbria cum contemptu aspicitur: sed cum salute tangitur. Usque ad hanc horam et esurimus, et sitimus, et nudi sumus, et colaphizamur . Quid tam extremum, quid tam contemptibile? Tange, si fluxum sanguinis pateris: exiet virtus de illo cujus vestis est, et sanabit te. Fimbria modo tangenda proponebatur, quando ex eodem apostolo legebatur: Si enim quis viderit eum qui habet scientiam, in idolio recumbentem; nonne conscientia ejus, cum sit infirma, aedificabitur ad manducandum idolothyta? Et peribit infirmus in tua scientia, frater, propter quem Christus mortuus est? Quomodo putatis decipi posse simulacris homines, quae a Christianis honorari putant? Novit, inquit, Deus cor meum. Sed frater tuus non novit cor tuum. Si infirmus es, cave majorem aegritudinem: si firmus es, cura fratris infirmitatem. Qui vident ista, aedificantur ad alia, ut non tantum ibi manducare, sed et sacrificare desiderent. Ecce perit infirmus in tua scientia frater. Audi, frater: si contemnebas infirmum, etiam fratrem contemnis? Expergiscere. Quid, si in ipsum Christum peccas? Attende enim quod nullo pacto possis contemnere. Sic autem, inquit, peccantes in fratres, et percutientes conscientiam eorum infirmam, in Christum peccatis. Eant nunc, qui ista contemnunt, et recumbant in idolio: nonne erunt prementes, non tangentes? et cum recubuerint in idolio, veniant et impleant ecclesiam; non salutem accepturi, sed pressuram facturi.

12.8 PL 38, 418

8. But thou wilt say, I am afraid lest I offend those above me. By all means be afraid of offending them, and so thou wilt not offend God. For thou who art afraid lest thou offend those above thee, see whether there be not One above him whom thou art afraid of offending. By all means then be loth to offend those above thee. This is an established rule with thee. But then is it not plain, that he must on no account be offended, who is above all others? Run over now the list of those above thee. First are thy father and mother, if they are educating thee aright; if they are bringing thee up for Christ; they are to be heard in all things, they must be obeyed in every command; let them enjoin nothing against one above themselves, and so let them be obeyed. And who, thou wilt say, is above him who begat me? He who created thee. For man begets, but God creates. How it is that man begets, he does not know; and what he shall beget, he does not know. But He who saw thee that He might make thee, before that he whom He made existed, is surely above thy father. Thy country again should be above thy very parents; so that whereinsoever thy parents enjoin aught against thy country, they are not to be listened to. And whatsoever thy country enjoin against God, it is not to be listened to. For if thou wilt be healed, if after the issue of blood, if after twelve years’ continuance in that disease, if after having spent thine all upon physicians, and not having received health, thou dost wish at length to be made whole; O woman, whom I am addressing as a figure of the Church, thy father enjoineth thee this, and thy people that. But thy Lord saith to thee, “Forget thine own people, and thy father’s house.” For what good? for what advantage? with what useful result? “Because the King hath desired thy beauty.” He hath desired what He made, since when deformed He loved thee, that He might make thee beautiful. For thee unbelieving, and deformed, He shed His Blood, and He made thee faithful and beauteous, He hath loved His own gifts in thee. For what didst thou bring to thy spouse? What didst thou receive for dowry from thy former father, and former people? Was it not the excesses and the rags of sins? Thy rags He cast away, thy robe impure He tore asunder. He pitied thee that He might adorn thee. He adorned thee, that He might love thee.

Majoris alicujus metu recumbentes in idolio. Observantia in majorem quemque sit ordinata. Sed timeo, inquies, ne offendam majorem. Time prorsus, ne offendas majorem; et non offendis Deum. Qui enim times, ne offendas majorem, vide ne forte sit major isto, quem times offendere. Majorem certe noli offendere. Haec tibi regula proponitur. Nonne manifestum est, eum minime offendendum, qui major est caeteris? Discute nunc majores tuos. Primi tibi sunt pater et mater: si recte educantes, si in Christum nutrientes; audiendi in omnibus, obtemperandum eis in omni jussione; contra majorem nihil jubeant, et serviatur illis. Quis est, inquis, major eo qui me generavit? Ille qui te ipsum creavit. Generat enim homo, creat Deus. Unde generat homo, nescit: quid generaturus sit, nescit. Ille qui te vidit ut faceret, antequam esset quem fecit, certe major est patre tuo. Major sit patria et ipsis parentibus tuis; ut quidquid jusserint parentes contra patriam, non audiantur. Et quidquid jusserit patria contra Deum, non audiatur. Si enim sanari vis, si post fluxum sanguinis, si post duodecim annos in illo morbo, si post consumpta omnia in medicis, et non recepta sanitate aliquando vis sana fieri, o mulier, quam alloquor in typo Ecclesiae, jubet illud pater tuus, et illud jubet populus tuus. Sed dicit tibi Dominus tuus, Obliviscere populum tuum et domum patris tui. Quo bono? quo fructu? qua mercede? Quoniam concupivit, inquit, rex decorem tuum . Concupivit quod fecit: quoniam ut pulchram faceret, foedam amavit. Pro infideli et foeda sanguinem fudit, fidelem ac pulchram reddidit, dona sua in te amavit. Quid enim sponso tuo contulisti? Quid in dotem a priore patre et priore populo accepisti? Nonne luxurias et pannos peccatorum? Abjecit pannos tuos, discidit cilicium tuum: misertus est, ut ornaret; ornavit, ut amaret.

12.9 PL 38, 418

9. What need of more, Brethren. Ye are Christians, and have heard, that “If ye sin against the brethren, and wound their weak conscience, ye sin against Christ.” Do not disregard it, if ye would not be wiped out of the book of life. How long shall I go about to speak in bright and pleasing terms to you, what my grief forceth me to speak in some sort, and will not suffer me to keep secret? Whosoever they are who are minded to disregard these things, and sin against Christ, let them only consider what they are doing. We wish the rest of the Heathen to be gathered in; and ye are stones in their way: they have a wish to come; they stumble, and so return. For they say in their hearts, Why should we leave the gods whom the very Christians worship as we do? God forbid, thou wilt say, that I should worship the gods of the Gentiles. I know, I understand, I believe thee. But what account art thou making of the consciences of the weak which thou art wounding? What account art thou making of their price, if thou disregard the purchase? Consider for how great a price was the purchase made. “Through thy knowledge,” saith the Apostle, “shall the weak brother perish;” that knowledge which thou professest to have, in that thou knowest that an idol is nothing, and that in thy mind thou art thinking only of God, and so sittest down in the idol’s temple. In this knowledge the weak brother perisheth. And lest thou shouldest pay no regard to the weak brother, he added, “for whom Christ died.” If thou wouldest disregard him, yet consider his Price, and weigh the whole world in the balance with the Blood of Christ. And lest thou shouldest still think that thou art sinning against a weak brother, and so esteem it after that he had heard that he was “Peter,” a trivial fault, and of small account, he saith, “Ye sin against Christ.” For men are in the habit of saying, I sin against man; am I sinning against God?” Deny then that Christ is God. Dost thou dare deny that Christ is God? Hast thou learned this other doctrine, when thou didst sit at meat in the idol’s temple? The school of Christ doth not admit that doctrine. I ask; Where learnedst thou that Christ is not God? The Pagans are wont to say so. Seest thou what bad associations do? Seest thou, “that evil communications corrupt good manners?” There thou canst not speak of the Gospel, and thou dost hear others talking of idols. There thou losest the truth that Christ is God; and what thou dost drink in there, thou vomitest out in the Church. It may be thou art bold enough to speak here; bold enough to mutter among the crowds; “Was not then Christ a man? Was He not crucified?” This hast thou learned of the Pagans. Thou hast lost thy soul’s health, thou hast not touched the border. On this point then touch again the border, and receive health. As I taught thee to touch it in this that is written, “Whoso seeth a brother sit at meat in the idol’s temple;” touch it also concerning the Divinity of Christ. The same border said of the Jews, “Whose are the fathers, and of whom as concerning the flesh Christ came, who is over all, God blessed for ever.” Behold, against Whom, even the Very God, thou dost sin, when thou sittest down with false gods.

Scandalum fratri, peccatum est in Christum. Quid plura, fratres? Christiani audistis, quia peccantes in fratres, et percutientes conscientiam eorum infirmam, in Christum peccatis. Nolite contemnere, si non vultis deleri de libro vitae. Quamdiu conamur luculenter et delectabiliter vobis dicere, quod dolor noster cogit quomodocumque dicere, et tacere non permittit? Quicumque voluerint ista contemnere, in Christum peccant, videant quid agant. Paganos reliquos colligi volumus, lapides estis in via; venire volentes offendunt, et redeunt. Dicunt enim in cordibus suis: Quare nos relinquamus deos, quos Christiani ipsi nobiscum colunt? Absit, a me, inquit, ut ego deos Gentium colam. Novi, intelligo, credo. Quid facis de conscientia infirmi, quam percutis? Quid facis de pretio, si contemnis quod emptum est? Vide quanti emptum est, Peribit, inquit, infirmus in tua scientia: quam te dicis habere, ut scias quia nihil est idolum, et animo cogites Deum, et sic recumbas in idolio. In hac scientia perit infirmus. Et ne contemnas infirmum, addidit, propter quem Christus mortuus est. Quem vis contemnere, pretium ipsius attende, et cum morte Christi totum mundum appende. Et ne adhuc putares te in infirmum peccare, et leve duceres peccatum ac parvi penderes, In Christum, inquit, peccatis. Solent enim homines dicere: In hominem pecco, numquid in Deum? Nega Christum Deum. Audes negare Christum Deum? An aliud, in idolio cum recumberes, didicisti? Non admittit istam doctrinam Christi doctrina. Quaero ubi didiceris non esse Christum Deum. Pagani hoc solent dicere. Vides quid faciunt mensae malae? Vides quoniam corrumpunt mores bonos colloquia mala ? Tu ibi de Evangelio loqui non potes, et de idolis loquentes audis. Amittis ibi quod Christus Deus est: et quod ibi bibis, in Ecclesia vomis. Forte hic audes loqui, forte inter turbas audes murmurare: Numquid Christus non homo fuit? nonne crucifixus est? A Paganis hoc didicisti, salutem perdidisti, fimbriam non tetigisti. Tange et in hoc fimbriam, recipe salutem. Sicut eam te tangere docuimus in eo quod scriptum est, Qui viderit fratrem in idolio recumbentem: tange illam et de divinitate Christi. De Judaeis dicebat eadem fimbria, Quorum patres, et ex quibus Christus secundum carnem, qui est super omnia Deus benedictus in saecula . Ecce in quem verum Deum peccas, dum discumbis apud deos falsos.

12.10 PL 38, 419

10. It is no god, you will say; because it is the tutelary genius of Carthage. As though if it were Mars or Mercury, it would be a god. But consider in what light it is esteemed by them; not what it is in itself. For I know also as well as thou, that it is but a stone. If this “genius” be any ornament, let the citizens of Carthage live well; and they themselves will be this “genius” of Carthage. But if the “genius” be a devil, ye have heard in that same Scripture, “The things which the Gentiles sacrifice, they sacrifice to devils, and not to God; and I would not that ye should have fellowship with devils.” We know well that it is no God; would that they knew it too! but because of those weak ones who do not know it, their conscience ought not to be wounded. It is this that the Apostle warns us of. For that they regard that statue as something divine, and take it for a god, the altar is witness. What does the altar there, if it be not accounted a god? Let no one tell me; it is no deity, it is no God. I have said already, “Would that they only knew this, as we all do.” But how they regard it, for what they take it, and what they do about it, that altar is witness. It is convincing against the intentions of all who worship there, grant that it may not be convincing also against those who sit at meat with them!

Inepta excusatio recumbentium in idolio. Non est, inquit, Deus; quia genium est Carthaginis. Quasi si Mars aut Mercurius esset, Deus esset. Sed quomodo ab ipsis habeatur, attende; non quid sit. Nam et ego tecum scio quia lapis est. Si genium ornamentum est aliquod; cives Carthaginis bene vivant, et ipsi erunt genium Carthaginis. Si autem genium daemonium est, audisti et ibi: Quae immolant Gentes, daemonibus immolant, et non Deo: nolo vos socios fieri daemoniorum . Novimus quia non est Deus; utinam et ipsi sic norint: sed propter eos qui hoc non norunt infirmos, non debet percuti conscientia ipsorum. Hoc monet Apostolus. Nam et illi quod numen habeant et pro numine accipiant illam statuam, ara testatur. Quid illic facit ara, si illud non habetur pro numine? Nemo mihi dicat. Non est numen, non est Deus. Jam dixi, Utinam sic ipsi norint hoc, quomodo novimus omnes nos. Sed quid habeant, pro qua re habeant, quid ibi faciant, ara illa testatur. Convicit omnium colentium mentes, non convincat recumbentes.

12.11 PL 38, 419

11. Yes, let not Christians press the Church, if the Pagans do. She is the Body of Christ. Were we not saying, that the Body of Christ was pressed, and not touched. He endured those who pressed Him; and was looking out for those who “touched” Him. And, Brethren, I would that if the Body of Christ be pressed by Pagans, by whom it is wont to be pressed; that at least Christians would not press the Body of Christ. Brethren, it is my business to speak to you, my business it is to speak to Christians; “For what have I to do to judge them that are without?” the Apostle himself saith. Them we address in another way, as being weak. With them we must deal softly, that they may hear the truth; in you the corruption must be cut out. If ye ask whereby the Pagans are to be gained over, whereby they are to be illuminated, and called to salvation; forsake their solemnities, forsake their trifling shows; and then if they do not consent to our truth, let them blush at their own scantiness.

Corpus Christi premere et tangere. Sed non premant Christiani, si premunt Pagani. Corpus Christi est. Nonne hoc dicebamus, quia corpus Christi premebatur, et non tangebatur,? Tolerabat ille prementes, quaerebat tangentes. Atque utinam, fratres, a Paganis prematur corpus Christi, a quibus premi solet; Christiani non premant corpus Christi. Fratres, ad nos pertinet vobis dicere, ad nos pertinet Christianis loqui. Quid enim mihi de his qui foris sunt judicare? ipse Apostolus ait . Illos aliter alloquimur, tanquam infirmos, Blandiendum est illis, ut audiant veritatem: in vobis secanda putredo est. Si quaeritis unde vincantur Pagani, unde illuminentur, unde ad salutem vocentur: deserite solemnitates eorum, deserite nugas ipsorum; et si non consentiunt veritati nostrae, erubescant paucitati suae.

12.12 PL 38, 420

12. If he who is over thee be a good man, he is thy nourisher; if a bad man, he is thy tempter. Receive the nourishment in the one case with gladness, and in the temptation show thyself approved. Be thou gold. Regard this world as the furnace of the goldsmith; in one narrow place are there things, gold, chaff, fire. To the two former the fire is applied, the chaff is burned, and the gold purified. A man has yielded to threats, and been led away to the idol’s temple: Alas! I bewail the chaff; I see the ashes. Another has not yet yielded to threats nor terrors; has been brought before the judge, and stood firm in his confession, and has not bent down to the idol image: what does the flame with him? Does it not purify the gold? Stand, fast then, Brethren, in the Lord; greater in power, is He who hath called you. Be not afraid of the threats of the ungodly. Bear with your enemies; in them ye have those for whom ye may pray; let them by no means terrify you. This is saving health, draw out in this feast here from this source; here drink that wherewith ye may be satisfied, and not in those other feasts, that only whereby ye may be maddened. Stand fast in the Lord. Ye are silver, ye shall be gold. This similitude is not our own, it is out of Holy Scripture. Ye have read and heard, “As gold in the furnace hath He tried them, and received them as a burnt-offering.” See what ye shall be among the treasures of God. Be ye rich as touching God, not as if to make Him rich, but as to become rich from Him. Let Him replenish you; admit nought else into your heart.

Praelatus seu bonus seu malus, piis nocere non valet. Bonus si fuerit qui tibi praeest, nutritor tuus est: malus si fuerit, tentator tuus est. Et nutrimenta libenter accipe, et in tentatione approbare. Esto aurum. Attende mundum istum tanquam fornacem aurificis: in uno angusto loco tria sunt, aurum, palea, ignis. Ad illa duo ignis apponitur, palea uritur, aurum purgatur. Cessit nescio quis minis, et adductus est ad idolium: vae mihi, quia paleam plango, cinerem video. Alius non cessit minis, non cessit terroribus ; adductus ad judicem, stetit in confessione sua, non est flexus ad idolium: quid facit flamma? Nonne aurum purgat? State in Domino, fratres: potentior est qui vocavit vos. Minas impiorum ne timueritis. Inimicos patimini; habetis pro quibus oretis; prorsus non vos terreant. Haec est sanitas, haurite hinc in isto convivio: hic bibite, unde satiemini, non illic, unde insaniatis. State in Domino. Argentei estis, aurum eritis. Ista similitudo non a nobis est, de divina Scriptura est. Legistis, audistis: Sicut aurum in fornace probavit illos; et sicut holocausti nostiam accepit illos . Ecce quid eritis ad thesauros Dei. Estote divites de Deo: non eum facturi divitem, sed de illo futuri divites. Impleat vos, aliud non admittatis ad cor vestrum.

12.13 PL 38, 420

13. Do we lift up ourselves unto pride, or tell you to be despisers against the powers ordained? Not so. Do ye again who are sick on this point, touch also that border of the garment? The Apostle himself saith, “Let every soul be subject unto the higher powers, for there is no power but of God, the powers that be are ordained of God. He then who resisteth the power, resisteth the ordinance of God.” But what if it enjoin what thou oughtest not to do? In this case by all means disregard the power through fear of Power. Consider these several grades of human powers. If the magistrate enjoin anything, must it not be done? Yet if his order be in opposition to the Proconsul, thou dost not surely despise the power, but choosest to obey a greater power. Nor in this case ought the less to be angry, if the greater be preferred. Again, if the Proconsul himself enjoin anything, and the Emperor another thing, is there any doubt, that disregarding the former, we ought to obey the latter? So then if the Emperor enjoin one thing, and God another, what judge ye? Pay me tribute, submit thyself to my allegiance. Right, but not in an idol’s temple. In an idol’s temple He forbids it. Who forbids it? A greater Power. Pardon me then: thou threatenest a prison, He threateneth hell. Here must thou at once take to thee thy “faith as a shield, whereby thou mayest be able to quench all the fiery darts of the enemy.”

Observantia potestatum ordinata. Numquid in superbiam vos erigimus, aut dicimus vobis ut adversus potestates ordinatas contemptores sitis? Non hoc dicimus. Qui et hinc aegrotatis, tangite et hinc fimbriam illam vestimenti. Ipse dicit Apostolus: Omnis anima potestatibus sublimioribus subdita sit: non est enim potestas nisi a Deo. Quae autem sunt, a Deo ordinatae sunt. Qui autem resistit potestati, Dei ordinationi resistit . Sed quid, si illud jubeat, quod non debes facere? Hic sane contemne potestatem, timendo potestatem. Ipsos humanarum rerum gradus advertite. Si aliquid jusserit curator, nonne faciendum est? Tamen si contra proconsulem jubeat, non utique contemnis potestatem, sed eligis majori servire. Nec hinc debet minor irasci, si major praelatus est. Rursum si aliquid ipse proconsul jubeat, et aliud jubeat imperator, numquid dubitatur isto contempto illi esse serviendum? Ergo si aliud imperator, et aliud Deus, quid judicatis? Solve tributum, esto mihi in obsequium. Recte, sed non in idolio. In idolio prohibet. Quis prohibet? Major potestas. Da veniam: tu carcerem, ille gehennam minatur. Hinc jam tibi assumenda est fides tua tanquam scutum, in quo possis omnia ignita jacula inimici exstinguere .

12.14 PL 38, 421

14. But one of these powers is plotting, and contriving evil designs against thee. Well: he is but sharpening the razor wherewith to shave the hair, but not to cut the head. Ye have but just now heard this that I have said in the Psalm, “Thou hast worked deceit like a sharp razor.” Why did He compare the deceit of a wicked man in power to a razor? Because it does not reach, save to our superfluous parts. As hairs on our body seem as it were superfluous, and are shaven off without any loss of the flesh; so whatsoever an angry man in power can take from thee, count only among thy superfluities. He takes away thy poverty; can he take away thy wealth? Thy poverty is thy wealth in thy heart. Thy superfluous things only hath he power to take away, these only hath he power to injure, even though he had license given him so far as to hurt the body. Yea even this life itself to those whose thoughts are of another life, this present life, I say, may be reckoned among the things superfluous. For so the Martyrs have despised it. They did not lose life, but they gained Life.

Dolus potentis mali novaculae comparatur. Sed insidiatur contra te potens, et molitur contra te potens: acuit novaculam unde capillos radat, non unde caput incidat. Quod dixi, modo audistis in Psalmo: Sicut novacula acuta fecisti dolum . Quare dolum potentis mali novaculae comparavit? Quia non admittitur, nisi ad superflua nostra. Sicut capilli in corpore nostro tanquam superflui videntur, et sine detrimento carnis raduntur; sic quidquid potest tibi facere iratus potens, inter superflua tua numera. Tollit paupertatem tuam: numquid tollit divitias tuas? Paupertas tua, divitiae tuae in corde tuo. Superflua tua potuit tollere, damno potuit afficere, permissus et usque ad laedendum corpus. Etiam ista vita, cogitantibus aliam vitam; ista, inquam, vita inter superflua deputanda est. Nam et martyres contempserunt illam. Non vitam perdiderunt, sed vitam acquisierunt.

12.15 PL 38, 421

15. Be sure, Brethren, that enemies have no power against the faithful, except so far as it profiteth them to be tempted and proved. Of this be sure, Brethren, let no one say ought against it. Cast all your care upon the Lord, throw yourselves wholly and entirely upon Him. He will not withdraw Himself that ye should fall. He who created us, hath given us security touching our very hairs. “Verily I say unto you, even the hairs of your head are all numbered.” Our hairs are numbered by God; how much more is our conduct known to Him to whom our hairs are thus known? See then, how that God doth not disregard our least things. For if He disregarded them, He would not create them. For He verily both created our hairs, and still taketh count of them. But thou wilt say, though they are preserved at present, perhaps they will perish. On this point also hear His word, “Verily I say unto you, there shall not an hair of your head perish.” Why art thou afraid of man, O man, whose place is in the Bosom of God? Fall not out of His Bosom; whatsoever thou shall suffer there, will avail to thy salvation, not to thy destruction. Martyrs have endured the tearing of their limbs, and shall Christians fear the injuries of Christian times? He who would do thee an injury now, can only do it in fear. He does not say openly, come to the idol-feast; he does not say openly, come to my altars, and banquet there. And if he should say so, and thou wast to refuse, let him make a complaint of it, let him bring it as an accusation and charge against thee: “He would not come to my altars, he would not come to my temple, where I worship.” Let him say this. He does not dare; but in his guile he contrives another attack. Make ready thy hair; he is sharpening the razor; he is about to take off thy superfluous things, to shave what thou must soon leave behind thee. Let him take off what shall endure, if he can. This powerful enemy, what has he taken away? what great thing has he taken away? That which a thief or housebreaker could take: in his utmost rage, he can but take what a robber can. Even if he should have license given him to the slaying of the very body, what does he take away, but what the robber can take? I did him too much honour, when I said, “a robber.” For be the robber who and what he may, he is a man. He takes from thee what a fever, or an adder, or a poisonous mushroom can take. Here lies the whole power of the rage of men, to do what a mushroom can! Men eat a poisonous mushroom, and they die. Lo! in what frail estate is the life of man; which sooner or later thou must abandon; do not struggle then in such wise for it, as that thou shouldest be abandoned thyself.

Securitas piorum sub Dei praesidio. Certi estote, fratres, inimicos non admitti adversus fideles, nisi quantum prodest tentandis et probandis fidelibus. Certi estote, fratres, nemo aliud dicat. Omnem curam vestram super Dominum mittite, prorsus vos ipsos totos projicite in illum. Non se subducit, ut cadatis. Ille qui nos creavit, et de ipsis capillis nostris securitatem nobis dedit. Amen dico vobis, inquit, et capilli capitis vestri omnes numerati sunt . Capilli nostri numerati sunt Deo: quanto magis mores nostri, cui sic noti sunt capilli nostri? Videte, quia minima nostra non contemnit Deus. Nam si contemneret, nec crearet. Nam et capillos nostros ipse utique creavit, et numeratos habet. Sed modo cum sint, inquis, forte peribunt. Et hinc audi vocem ejus: Amen dico vobis, capillus capitis vestri non peribit . Quid times hominem, o homo in sinu Dei positus? Tu de illius sinu noli cadere: quidquid ibi passus fueris, ad salutem valebit, non ad perniciem. Laniatus membrorum martyres pertulerunt, et timent Christiani injurias temporum Christianorum? Qui tibi facit injuriam modo, timens facit. Non dicit aperte, Veni ad idolum: non dicit aperte, Veni ad aras meas, ibi convivare. Et si dixerit, et nolueris, hoc conqueratur, hoc in postulationem, hoc in querimoniam deponat: Noluit venire ad aras meas, noluit venire ad templum quod veneror. Hoc dicat. Non audet dicere: sed alia machinatur dolose. Para capillos, novaculam acuit: ablaturus est superflua tua, rasurus quidquid relicturus es. Tollat quidquid permanebit, si potest. Quid tulit potens nocens? quid magnum tulit? Quod fur, quod effractor; ut multum saeviat, quod latro. Si et ad ipsum corpus occidendum permissus fuerit, quid tollit nisi quod latro? Honoravi, cum dixi, Latro. Nam qualiscumque latro, homo est. Quod febris, quod scorpius, quod fungus malus. Ista tota potentia saevientium est, facere quod fungus. Manducant homines fungum malum, et moriuntur. Ecce in qua fragilitate est vita humana: quam quandoque relicturus es, noli pro illa sic pugnare, ut tu relinquaris.

12.16 PL 38, 422

16. Christ is our Life; think then of Christ. He came to suffer, but also to be glorified; to be despised, but to be exalted also; to die; but also to rise again. If the labour alarm thee, see its reward. Why dost thou wish to arrive by softness at that to which nothing but hard labour can lead? Now thou art afraid, lest thou shouldest lose thy money; because thou earnest thy money with great labour. If thou didst not attain to thy money, which thou must some time or other lose, at all events when thou diest, without labour, wouldest thou desire without labour to attain to the Life eternal? Let that be of higher value in thine eyes, to which after all thy labours thou shalt in such sort attain as never more to lose it. If this money, to which thou hast attained after all thy labours on such condition as that thou must some time lose it, be of high value with thee; how much more ought we to long after those things which are everlasting!

Vita aeterna laboris merces. Vita nostra Christus est: Christum attende. Pati venit, sed et glorificari; contemni, sed etiam exaltari; mori, sed etiam resurgere. Opus te terret, mercedem vide. Quare vis pervenire delicatus ad eam rem, ad quam non perducit nisi labor? Sed times ne perdas argentum tuum; quia ad argentum tuum cum magno labore pervenisti. Si ad argentum quod quandoque vel moriens amissurus es, non pervenisti sine labore; ad vitam aeternam sine labore vis pervenire? Charior sit tibi illa, ad quam post omnes labores sic pervenies, ut nunquam amittas. Si hoc tibi charum est, ad quod post omnes labores sic pervenisti, ut aliquando amissurus sis; quanto magis illa perpetua desiderare debemus?

12.17 PL 38, 422

17. Give no credit to their words, neither be afraid of them. They say that we are enemies of their idols. May God so grant, and give all into our power, as He hath already given us that which we have broken down. For this I say, Beloved, that ye may not attempt to do it, when it is not lawfully in your power to do it; for it is the way of ill-regulated men, and the mad Circumcelliones, both to be violent when they have no power, and to be ever eager in their wishes to die without a cause. Ye heard what we read to you, all of you who were present in the Mappalia. “When the land shall have been given into your power” (he saith first, “into your power,” and so enjoined what was to be done); “then,” saith he, “ye shall destroy their altars, and break in pieces their groves, and hew down all their images.” When we shall have got the power, do this. When the power has not been given us, we do not do it; when it is given, we do not neglect it. Many Pagans have these abominations on their own estates; do we go and break them in pieces? No, for our first efforts are that the idols in their hearts should be broken down. When they too are made Christians themselves, they either invite us to so good a work, or anticipate us. At present we must pray for them, not be angry with them. If very painful feelings excite us, it is rather against Christians, it is against our brethren, who will enter into the Church in such a mind, as to have their body there, and their heart anywhere else. The whole ought to be within. If that which man seeth is within, why is that which God seeth without?

Idola nisi legitima potestas detur, non frangenda. Verbis ipsorum ne credatis, nec timeatis. Hostes nos dicunt idolorum suorum. Sic praestet Deus, et det omnia in potestate, quomodo dedit quod fractum est. Hoc enim dicimus Charitati vestrae, ne faciatis ista, quando in potestate vestra non est, ut faciatis illud. Pravorum hominum est, furiosorum Circumcellionum, et ubi potestatem non habent saevire, et velle mori properant sine causa. Audistis quae vobis legimus, omnes qui nuper in Mappalibus adfuistis. Cum data vobis fuerit terra in potestatem (prius ait, in potestatem, et sic dixit quae facienda sunt), aras eorum, inquit, destruetis, lucos eorum comminuetis, et omnes titulos eorum confringetis . Cum acceperitis potestatem, hoc facite. Ubi nobis non est data potestas, non facimus; ubi data est, non praetermittimus. Multi pagani habent istas abminationes in fundis suis: numquid accedimus, et confringimus? Prius enim agimus, ut idola in eorum corde frangamus. Quando christiani et ipsi facti fuerint, aut invitant nos ad tam bonum opus, aut praeveniunt nos. Modo orandum est pro illis, non irascendum illis. Si movet dolor magnus, adversum Christianos movet, adversum fratres nostros movet, qui sic volunt intrare in ecclesiam, ut hic corpus habeant, alibi cor. Totum intus esse debet. Si intus est quod videt homo, quare foris est quod videt Deus?

12.18 PL 38, 423

18. Now ye may know, Dearly Beloved, that these unite their murmurings with Heretics and with Jews. Heretics, Jews, and Heathens have made a unity against Unity. Because it has happened, that in some places the Jews have received chastisement because of their wickednesses; they charge and suspect us, or pretend, that we are always seeking the like treatment for them. Again, because it has happened that the heretics in some places have suffered the penalty of the laws for the impiety and fury of their deeds of violence; they say immediately that we are seeking by every means some harm for their destruction. Again, because it has been resolved that laws should be passed against the Heathen, yea for them rather, if they were only wise. (For as when silly boys are playing with the mud, and dirtying their hands, the strict master comes, shakes the mud out of their hands, and holds out their book; so has it pleased God by the hands of princes His subjects to alarm their childish, foolish hearts, that they may throw away the dirt from their hands, and set about something useful. And what is this something useful with the hands, but, “Break thy bread to the hungry, and bring the houseless poor into thy house”? But nevertheless these children escape from their master’s sight, and return stealthily to their mud, and when they are discovered they hide their hands that they may not be seen.) Because then it has so pleased God, they think that we are looking out for the idols everywhere, and that we break them down in all places where we have discovered them. How so? Are there not places before our very eyes in which they are? Or are we indeed ignorant where they are? And yet we do not break them down, because God has not given them into our power. When does God give them into our power? When the masters of these things shall become Christians. The master of a certain place has just lately wished this to be done. If he had not been minded to give the place itself to the Church, and only had given orders that there should be no idols on his property; I think that it ought to have been executed with the greatest devotion, that the soul of the absent Christian brother, who wishes on his land to return thanks to God, and would not that there should be anything there to God’s dishonour, might be assisted by his fellow-Christians. Added to this, that in this case he gave the place itself to the Church. And shall there be idols in the Church’s estate? Brethren, see then what it is that displeases the Heathens. It is but a little matter with them that we do not take them away from their estates, that we do not break them down: they would have them kept up even in our own places. We preach against idols, we take them away from the hearts of men; we are persecutors of idols; we openly profess it. Are we then to be the preservers of them? I do not touch them when I have not the power; I do not touch them when the lord of the property complains of it; but when he wishes it to be done, and gives thanks for it, I should incur guilt if I did it not.

Idololatrarum injustae querimoniae. Sciatis autem, charissimi, murmura illorum conjungere se cum haereticis, cum Judaeis. Haeretici, Judaei et Pagani unitatem fecerunt contra unitatem. Quia contigit ut in aliquibus locis disciplinam acciperent Judaei propter improbitates suas; criminantur, et suspicantur, aut fingunt, quia talia de illis semper quaeramus. Quia contigit ut alicubi haeretici poenas darent legibus pro impietate et furore violentiarum suarum; jam dicunt nos per omnia quaerere aliquam incommoditatem ipsorum ad perniciem. Rursus quia contra Paganos placuit ut leges ferrentur, imo pro Paganis, si sapiant (Sicut enim pueris insensatis ad lutum ludentibus, et manus inquinantibus, paedagogus cum venit severus, lutum de manu excutit, codicem porrigit: ita voluit Deus per principes subditos sibi terrere corda insensata puerilia, ut abjiciant lutum de manibus, et aliquid utile faciant. Quid est utile de manibus? Frange esurienti panem tuum, et egenum sine tecto induc in domum tuam . Et tamen pueri evadunt ab oculis paedagogi, et redeunt ad lutum furtim; et quando inveniuntur, abscondunt manus, ne videantur): quia ergo voluit Deus, putant nos ubicumque quaerere idola; quae cum invenerimus, in omnibus locis frangere. Quare? Non ante nos sunt loca, in quibus sunt? Aut vere ignoramus ubi sint ista? Et tamen non facimus: quia non dedit in potestatem Deus. Quando dat Deus in potestatem? Quando christianus erit cujus res est. Modo factum voluit cujus res est. Si nollet ipsum locum dare Ecclesiae, et tantum juberet in re sua non esse idola; puto quia debuit summa devotione fieri, ut a Christianis adjuvaretur absens christiana anima, quae in terra vult Deo gratias agere, non vult ibi aliquid esse in contumeliam Dei. Huc accedit, quia Ecclesiae dedit ipsa loca. Et in re Ecclesiae idola futura erant? Fratres, ecce quid displicet Paganis. Parum est illis quia de villis ipsorum non illa tollimus, non illa frangimus: et in nostris volunt ea servari. Contra idola praedicamus, de cordibus illa tollimus: sumus persecutores idolorum: profitemur. Numquid servatores? Non facio ubi non possum; non facio ubi conqueritur dominus rei: ubi autem vult fieri, et gratias agit; reus ero; si non fecero.

Philip Schaff (ed.), Buffalo/New York: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1886-1889. Public domain: English translation first published 1885-1900 (Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series). Latin: Migne, Patrologia Latina (1844-1855), public domain; transcription from Corpus Corporum (University of Zurich).

Save for later

Enter your email and we will send you a sign-in link. No password. What you save (articles, verses, chapters, documents) follows you to any device.